It's stuck in 2013
The interface, the search and the mobile app have gone essentially untouched for a decade. Adding a book still takes more taps than it should, and nothing about the experience suggests it was designed for a phone.
Goodreads has been the default place to track reading for over a decade, and for a straight shelf of books it still works. The problem is everything else.
Your taste does not stop at books. The restaurants you recommend, the films you defend, the wines you remember β Goodreads has nowhere to put any of it, and no intelligence to help you when you do. Here is how the two compare in 2026.
| Feature | TheLysts | Goodreads |
|---|---|---|
| AI List Creation | β Yes. Share a link, screenshot or PDF and AI builds the list for you. | β No. Every shelf is added by hand, one title at a time. |
| AI Smart Columns & Auto-Fill | β Yes. Columns are suggested for the kind of list, then auto-filled. | β No. Fixed fields only β no custom columns of your own. |
| AI Item Suggestions | β Yes. Suggests what to add next based on the list you are building. | β οΈ Partial. Recommendations exist, but only for books and only from ratings. |
| Multi-Category Lists | β Yes. Restaurants, travel, films, wines, watches β any category. | β No. Books, and nothing but books. |
| Near Me / Geo-Discovery | β Yes. Items can be geo-tagged, so a list becomes a map. | β No. No location layer at all. |
| Built-In Chat & Sharing | β Yes. Chat and real-time collaboration inside the app. | β οΈ Partial. Comments and groups, but no real-time sharing or chat. |
| Private Groups | β Yes. Share a list with a chosen group and keep it off the public web. | β οΈ Partial. Groups exist but are dated and hard to keep private. |
| List Monetization | β Yes. Publish paid lists and earn from your recommendations. | β No. No way for a curator to earn anything. |
| Modern UI / Mobile | β Yes. Mobile-first, built for the phone you actually list on. | β No. An interface that has barely changed since 2013. |
| Free to Use | β Yes. Free on iOS and Android, with AI included. | β Yes. Free, but funded by ads and owned by a retailer. |
The interface, the search and the mobile app have gone essentially untouched for a decade. Adding a book still takes more taps than it should, and nothing about the experience suggests it was designed for a phone.
If you also track restaurants, films, wines or places to visit, none of it belongs on Goodreads. You end up with your taste scattered across four apps and a notes file.
There is no way to import a reading list from a screenshot or an article, no column suggestions, and no help filling anything in. Every shelf is manual labour.
People with genuinely good reading recommendations have no way to earn from them. The value your curation creates goes to the platform and its ads.
Nothing stops you keeping a Goodreads account for the reading log. But when the list matters β when someone is actually going to use it β it belongs somewhere that can hold the context, reach the people you meant it for, and pay you back for the work.
Yes, and it goes further. TheLysts covers books the way Goodreads does β titles, authors, ratings, notes β and then covers everything else too, with AI list creation, custom auto-filled columns, sharing and monetisation that Goodreads has never offered.
There is no one-click Goodreads import yet. In practice you can move a shelf quickly by sharing your Goodreads list URL, a screenshot of it, or an exported PDF into TheLysts β AI reads it and rebuilds the list as a structured list you can edit.
Yes. TheLysts is free on iOS and Android, and AI list creation is included at no extra cost. There is no credit card required to start.