Letterboxd is genuinely good at what it does. If your only concern is logging films and reading sharp reviews, it has earned its place.

But a watchlist is one slice of your taste. The restaurants you send people to, the books you press on friends, the places you would go back to β€” none of that fits, and Letterboxd was never trying to make it fit. Here is the honest comparison.

TheLysts vs Letterboxd at a glance

Feature TheLysts Letterboxd
AI List Creation Yes. Build a list from a link, screenshot or PDF in seconds. No. Lists are assembled film by film, by hand.
AI Smart Columns & Auto-Fill Yes. Suggested columns, auto-filled for the kind of list. No. Film metadata only β€” no fields of your own.
AI Item Suggestions Yes. Suggests what belongs on the list you are building. Partial. Recommendations come from the community, not from your list.
Multi-Category Lists Yes. Films, food, travel, books, products β€” all in one app. No. Films only, by design.
Near Me / Geo-Discovery Yes. Geo-tagged items turn a saved list into a map. No. No location features.
Built-In Chat & Sharing Yes. Chat and real-time collaboration on any list. Partial. Comments and activity, but no chat or live co-editing.
Private Groups Yes. Share with a chosen group, or keep it entirely private. Partial. Lists are public or private, with no group in between.
List Monetization Yes. Turn your best lists into paid lists. No. No earning path for curators.
Modern UI / Mobile Yes. Mobile-first and fast. Yes. Well designed, with a strong visual identity.
Free to Use Yes. Fully free, AI included. Partial. Free tier is limited; Pro and Patron unlock basics like filters and stats.

What Letterboxd Does Well

The best film community online

Letterboxd's reviews are funny, well written and genuinely useful. That culture is real and it is not something a feature list can replicate.

Beautiful, opinionated design

The app knows exactly what it is. Poster-led layouts, clean typography and a diary that makes logging films feel worth doing.

Serious film data

Cast, crew, runtimes, release variants and streaming availability are all there and accurate β€” the depth a film-only app can afford.

Where Letterboxd Falls Short

Films only, forever

That is the product's whole premise, so it will not change. Everything else you would recommend has to live somewhere else.

No AI, all manual work

Building a themed list of thirty films means adding thirty films by hand. Nothing imports, nothing auto-fills.

No location-based discovery

There is no notion of where you are, so a list can never become a map of what is nearby.

Creators cannot earn

Some of the most-followed list makers on the platform have audiences a publisher would pay for, and no way to earn from them.

Pay-to-unlock basic features

Filters, stats and an ad-free experience sit behind Pro and Patron tiers, which is a lot of paywall for features most apps include.

Who Should Try TheLysts Alongside Letterboxd?

  • Film lovers who also want lists for restaurants, travel and books without opening three more apps.
  • People who make themed lists and would rather AI did the assembling.
  • Curators whose recommendations are good enough that people would pay for them.
  • Anyone who wants a list to be useful on the ground, with places tagged and mapped.

Keep logging films. Bring the rest with you.

This is not a case for deleting Letterboxd β€” keep the diary. TheLysts is where the other ninety percent of your taste goes: structured properly, shareable in one tap, and yours to monetise if you want to.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which is better for movies, TheLysts or Letterboxd?

For logging films, writing reviews and reading a knowledgeable film community, Letterboxd is still the stronger choice. For building shareable film lists alongside everything else you recommend β€” with AI assembling them and the option to earn β€” TheLysts is the better fit. Plenty of people use both.

Can I track movies on TheLysts?

Yes. Films are a category like any other: build a watchlist or a themed list, add ratings, notes and links, and share it publicly, with a private group or not at all. AI can build the list from an article or a screenshot instead of you adding each title.

Ready to switch?

Download TheLysts free and start building smarter lists today.