The best film community online
Letterboxd's reviews are funny, well written and genuinely useful. That culture is real and it is not something a feature list can replicate.
Letterboxd is genuinely good at what it does. If your only concern is logging films and reading sharp reviews, it has earned its place.
But a watchlist is one slice of your taste. The restaurants you send people to, the books you press on friends, the places you would go back to β none of that fits, and Letterboxd was never trying to make it fit. Here is the honest comparison.
| Feature | TheLysts | Letterboxd |
|---|---|---|
| AI List Creation | β Yes. Build a list from a link, screenshot or PDF in seconds. | β No. Lists are assembled film by film, by hand. |
| AI Smart Columns & Auto-Fill | β Yes. Suggested columns, auto-filled for the kind of list. | β No. Film metadata only β no fields of your own. |
| AI Item Suggestions | β Yes. Suggests what belongs on the list you are building. | β οΈ Partial. Recommendations come from the community, not from your list. |
| Multi-Category Lists | β Yes. Films, food, travel, books, products β all in one app. | β No. Films only, by design. |
| Near Me / Geo-Discovery | β Yes. Geo-tagged items turn a saved list into a map. | β No. No location features. |
| Built-In Chat & Sharing | β Yes. Chat and real-time collaboration on any list. | β οΈ Partial. Comments and activity, but no chat or live co-editing. |
| Private Groups | β Yes. Share with a chosen group, or keep it entirely private. | β οΈ Partial. Lists are public or private, with no group in between. |
| List Monetization | β Yes. Turn your best lists into paid lists. | β No. No earning path for curators. |
| Modern UI / Mobile | β Yes. Mobile-first and fast. | β Yes. Well designed, with a strong visual identity. |
| Free to Use | β Yes. Fully free, AI included. | β οΈ Partial. Free tier is limited; Pro and Patron unlock basics like filters and stats. |
Letterboxd's reviews are funny, well written and genuinely useful. That culture is real and it is not something a feature list can replicate.
The app knows exactly what it is. Poster-led layouts, clean typography and a diary that makes logging films feel worth doing.
Cast, crew, runtimes, release variants and streaming availability are all there and accurate β the depth a film-only app can afford.
That is the product's whole premise, so it will not change. Everything else you would recommend has to live somewhere else.
Building a themed list of thirty films means adding thirty films by hand. Nothing imports, nothing auto-fills.
There is no notion of where you are, so a list can never become a map of what is nearby.
Some of the most-followed list makers on the platform have audiences a publisher would pay for, and no way to earn from them.
Filters, stats and an ad-free experience sit behind Pro and Patron tiers, which is a lot of paywall for features most apps include.
This is not a case for deleting Letterboxd β keep the diary. TheLysts is where the other ninety percent of your taste goes: structured properly, shareable in one tap, and yours to monetise if you want to.
For logging films, writing reviews and reading a knowledgeable film community, Letterboxd is still the stronger choice. For building shareable film lists alongside everything else you recommend β with AI assembling them and the option to earn β TheLysts is the better fit. Plenty of people use both.
Yes. Films are a category like any other: build a watchlist or a themed list, add ratings, notes and links, and share it publicly, with a private group or not at all. AI can build the list from an article or a screenshot instead of you adding each title.